Renovating Q&A: Laminate vs. Real Wood Floors

Q.

We can’t decide between wood laminate and real wood floors. How do you decide?

A.

Well, your space may help decide for you, says certified kitchen designer Judy Scott, an associate for Home Depot. When it comes to wood floors, you have three options: solid wood planks, engineered wood floors (basically, a plywood material covered with a real wood layer), and wood laminate like Pergo (basically a plastic material created to look like wood). Solid wood, as it adds to the structure of your home, will add value to the house, can also be refinished over and over again and will likely be the most expensive and most involved process. But, says Scott, it can’t be placed below ground level (like in a basement) or in a kitchen or bathroom (potential water damage is too great to take the chance). Engineered wood can be refinished once or twice and is an easier, cheaper alternative, but, says Scott, won’t add value to your house. Wood laminate can be placed on any ground and can take any level of moisture or water, but can never be changed or refinished. And while it also doesn’t add value to your home, you can buy a “floating” version that snaps together instead of one that glues together, and just take it with you when you leave. Or, go supercheap and check out a product called Traffic Master Allure vinyl wood strips that connect with adhesive, and give you the look of real wood in a bathroom. Quick tip: If you have a squeak or groan in your floor before you put down laminate, you’ll have it after; screwing into the floor joists should stop it. Fix it first!  Get more renovation tips from the experts at The Nest.

-- Amy Spencer

May 22, 2009

See More: Renovating , Decor Tricks , DIY , Home Repairs , Painting & DIY , Style Solutions

share your opinion on this topic
Want to participate? Log in to share your thoughts.

We were debating on wood laminate and real wood floors for our kitchen renovation project and decided to go with the laminate due to costs on the materials and labor. We got the flooring at a great price through ProSource Wholesale Floorcoverings & it was easy to install on our own since we bought the floating snap-and-go kind. As with all first-time homeowner D.I.Y. projects, we had some setbacks. The dishwasher we hooked up on our own leaked and ruined a large majority of the brand new floor we had just installed. As painful as it was to buy more, replacing the damaged planks was easy & cheaper than reporting the incident to our homeowner's insurance. Even though my husband and I know it's not real wood... not a single person who has come through our kitchen has noticed - everyone thinks it's real! Furthermore, they are "floored" when they find out we put it in ourselves. The brand we used was Bruce; the planks were individual & it was much thicker than traditional laminate.

by bethyb02 on Oct 29, 2009